Meltwater channels and trenches
Agreement on the origin of the name of the “Missouri” River is difficult because too many contradictory explanations exist. The name apparently comes from a Siouan Indian word, “ouemessourita” or “emissourita,” translated by early French explorers as “those who have wooden dugout canoes,” or “river of the large canoes,” or “town of the large canoes,” or any of several other possibilities. One source says the term was the name the Illinois Indians used for the native people who lived in the Mississippi River Valley, probably mainly on the eastern (Illinois) side of the river; another source says they lived in what is now the State of Missouri.
The Missouri River originates near Three Forks, Montana, where the Gallatin, Jefferson, and Madison rivers come together. It flows 2,341 miles to St. Louis, where it joins the Mississippi River. This makes the combined Missouri-Mississippi River, at 3,709 miles, the fourth longest river in the world, after the Nile, Amazon, and Yangtze. The entire length was once riverine environment but, due to the dams that have been built along its route, approximately a third of the length is now reservoirs – lake environment rather than river. Listed from upstream to downstream, the dams are: Fort Peck in Montana, Garrison in North Dakota, Oahe, Big Bend, and Fort Randall in South Dakota, and Gavins Point on the South Dakota-Nebraska border.
Along with its valley, the Missouri River is largely a product of glaciation. Before North America was glaciated, all the drainage in North and South Dakota, eastern Montana, and northern Minnesota was north or northeastward into Canada. There was no “Missouri River” carrying drainage from the northern mid-continent region to the Gulf of Mexico. The way I define the Missouri River requires that its water ultimately reach the Gulf of Mexico as it does today, and that it carry water draining from the Rocky Mountains and northern Great Plains. Prior to glaciation, no such river existed. Why is the situation today so different than it was before the Ice Age?
The modern Missouri River Valley in North Dakota consists of several discrete valley segments that differ markedly from one another. Some of the segments are broad: six to twelve miles wide from edge to edge, with gentle slopes from the adjacent upland to the valley floor. Others are narrow: less than two miles wide, with rugged valley sides – even badlands slopes in places. Most of the wide segments trend from west to east whereas the narrow segments are mainly north-south. The Bismarck-Mandan area is one of only a few exceptions, and I’ll explain why shortly.
The west-east segments of the Missouri River Valley are wide because they coincide with much older valleys that existed long before the area was glaciated. Old, mature river valleys, which formed over long periods of time (hundreds of thousands or millions of years), tend to be broad with gentle slopes. Younger valleys formed more quickly (tens of thousands of years), and are usually narrower with steeper sides. An example of a wide segment is the forty-mile-long, west-east segment of the Missouri River Valley upstream from Garrison Dam. This part of the valley, now flooded by Lake Sakakawea, was once the route of a river that flowed east to Riverdale. However, the river didn’t turn south at Riverdale, as it does today. Rather, it continued eastward past Riverdale, and on past Turtle Lake and Mercer, flowing into northeastern North Dakota. For convenience, I’ll refer to this ancient river as the “McLean River.”
East of U. S. Highway 83, the route of the old McLean River valley is a broad, low area, partly buried beneath tens to hundreds of feet of glacial sediment. Lake Audubon, Turtle Lake, Lake Brekken, Lake Holmes, Lake Williams, Lake Peterson, Pelican Lake, Blue Lake, Brush Lake, and other smaller lakes mark the former route of the McLean River through eastern McLean County. However, continuing farther east, the McLean River valley becomes so deeply buried beneath glacial deposits that it would be nearly impossible to know its route from a study of the surface topography. Fortunately, hundreds of test holes were drilled during studies of the ground water resources of the glacial deposits so we have a good idea of the route the river followed into northeastern North Dakota.
Another wide, west-east trending segment of the modern Missouri River Valley, between Stanton and Washburn, is an eastward continuation of the modern Knife River. Prior to glaciation, the Knife River flowed east in its modern valley to Stanton, but it continued eastward from there, past Washburn. A few miles east of Washburn it turned slightly northeastward. The ancient Knife River joined the McLean River near the town of Mercer and the combined Knife-McLean River continued northeastward to the Devils Lake area. It then flowed north along the east side of Turtle Mountain area into Canada.
Still another wide segment of the Missouri River Valley in northwestern North Dakota extends from near the modern Missouri River /Yellowstone River confluence, northeastward to Williston.
This six-to-eight-mile-wide section of the valley coincides with the pre-glacial route of the Yellowstone River through that area. Prior to glaciation, the Yellowstone River continued to the north, past Williston, following a route that is now mainly buried. The pre-glacial route coincides with the modern route of the Little Muddy River as far as Zahl, about 30 miles north of Williston. North of Zahl, the old Yellowstone River valley into Canada is so deeply buried that its route is known only through drill-hole data. The river entered Saskatchewan about six miles north of Crosby.
The Missouri River Valley between Williston and New Town, now flooded by Lake Sakakawea, follows the same route as did an east-flowing, mid-Ice Age — but probably not pre-glacial – river. This part of the Missouri River Valley is somewhat narrower than most other east-west segments of the valley in North Dakota, and it is also younger than most of them. It is a continuation of a mid-Ice Age river that flowed east from Montana. In Montana, the route of this river coincides with the modern route of the Missouri River past Wolf Point, Poplar, and Culbertson. The Montana segment of the mid-Ice Age river joined the north-flowing Yellowstone River near Buford.
At Bismarck-Mandan, the Missouri River Valley is about two miles wide at the Interstate Highway 94 crossing, but on the south side of Bismarck the valley broadens to six miles wide. The widening southward seems contrary to my earlier comment that north-south segments of the valley tend to be narrow. There is a reason for this exception though. The valley widens at Bismarck-Mandan because, prior to glaciation, the Heart and Little Heart rivers, which today flow into the Missouri River, joined a few miles east of Bismarck. The combined (preglacial) Heart/Little Heart River continued flowing eastward, joining the Cannonball River in southern Burleigh County, near Moffit. The old, combined Heart/Little Heart valley still exists as a broad lowland south and southeast of Bismarck. It is now a wide spot in the Missouri River Valley.
The Heart/Little Heart river system was probably dammed several times by glacial ice advancing westward. Each time a glacier advanced, a lake formed ahead of – west of – it in the Heart/Little Heart valley. The lake (or lakes) are referred to as glacial Lake McKenzie. At least once, and possibly several times, glacial Lake McKenzie overflowed, carving what is now the Missouri River valley south of the Bismarck-Mandan area.
When the (preglacial?) Heart River flowed eastward, through the Bismarck area, it deposited a thick gravel deposit which now lies buried about 100 feet beneath the Missouri River. Bismarck’s new (2013) water-intake structure withdraws ground water from this old Heart River gravel deposit.
When the McLean River valley was blocked by a glacier in the Riverdale area midway through the Ice Age, a large proglacial lake formed ahead (to the west) of the ice in the valley. This lake might be considered to be the “original” Lake Sakakawea: an early ice-dammed lake that predated the Corps of Engineers version of Lake Sakakawea by thousands of years. When the lake overflowed, near where Garrison Dam is today, the resulting flood quickly carved a narrow spillway trench south to the Stanton area.
Similarly, the Knife River, which flowed past Stanton and on to the Washburn area, was dammed by glacial ice just east of Washburn and the valley was flooded upstream beyond Washburn. The resulting lake overflowed and spilled southward into the Burnt Creek-Square Butte Creek drainage, carving a narrow trench from a few miles east of Washburn to the Bismarck-Mandan area. The modern Missouri River flows in that trench today.
And, as I noted, when the Heart/Little Heart River was dammed by a glacier, which probably advanced as far west as Sterling, glacial Lake McKenzie formed. The lake overflowed southward, forming a new valley, now flooded by the northernmost part of Lake Oahe.
The youngest and narrowest segment of the Missouri River Valley in North Dakota is at New Town, between Four Bears Bridge and Van Hook Bay. As recently as 13,000 years ago, a glacier blocked the Missouri River from its route around the north and east side of New Town. The old river route (prior to 13,000 years ago) is now a broad valley, known as the “Van Hook Arm,” flooded by Lake Sakakawea. The glacier dammed the valley, causing a lake to form upstream (to the west) of the point of blockage. Thick layers of lake sediment, known as the “Crow-Flies-High silt,” were deposited in the ice-dammed “Crow-Flies-High Lake.” Crow-Flies-High Lake extended westward from the New Town area to near Williston. In many places between these two cities, exposures of the bedded lake silt deposits occur at elevations as high as 70 feet above the modern, maximum reservoir level (1850 feet) of Lake Sakakawea. The lake rose until it overflowed southward, cutting the channel now spanned by the Four Bears Bridge.
Other “Missouri” River Routes
Up to now, I’ve tried to explain the origin of the modern route of the Missouri River. That’s not the end of the story though. The modern route of the Missouri River is only the most recent of many routes that earlier “Missouri” rivers followed through North Dakota at various times during the Ice Age. These rivers also carried runoff water from as far away as the Rocky Mountains, through North Dakota, on its way to the Gulf of Mexico. However, most of these routes, mainly in northern and eastern North Dakota, are now buried beneath thick accumulations of glacial sediment. Whatever routes these rivers followed, they had to have flowed generally eastward and southward because their original, northerly and northeasterly routes into Canada were blocked by ice each time glaciers advanced into the state. Test drilling, done to study ground water resources, has helped us identify least least some parts of the old “Missouri” River routes. There are dozens of them.
One of several early routes of the Missouri River, determined by test-hole drilling, took the river southward past Cooperstown and Valley City to the southeastern corner of the state. Another route took the river southeastward past Jamestown. In the northern part of the state, rivers like the Yellowstone were diverted from their northerly routes to easterly and southeasterly routes, past places like Columbus, Kenmare, and Minot. These buried valleys can be considered to be early “Missouri” River routes. The array of buried river valleys is really amazing – and so complicated – and such a great number of possible routes exist, that it is impossible to work them all out. All of them are now buried beneath hundreds of feet of glacier sediment, and most of them have no surface evidence whatsoever.
However, not all of the early “Missouri River” routes through North Dakota are deeply buried. In the western part of the state, a version of a Missouri River formed when an early glacier advanced at least as far southwest as the Hebron area. The margin of that glacier coincided with what is now a prominent, broad valley, known as the Killdeer-Shields channel. The channel extends southeastward from the Killdeer Mountains, past Hebron and Glen Ullin, to the Fort Yates area, crossing the modern Missouri River Valley, and continuing through southwestern Emmons County into South Dakota. No river flows through the Killdeer-Shields channel today, but an early Missouri River flowed in it, perhaps for a longer period of time than the current Missouri River has flowed in its modern route. Interstate Highway 94 crosses the valley about half way between Dickinson and Mandan. Good views of the Killdeer-Shields channel can be seen just north of Richardton and between Hebron and Glen Ullin. Old U.S. Highway 10 and the Burlington Northern Santa Fe Railroad follow the old channel from Hebron to Glen Ullin.
I realize that my description of the changes in the routes the various “Missouri” Rivers have followed since the Ice Age began is complicated. Even so, it doesn’t begin to account for the evolution of all of the changes in the vast array of routes that rivers followed during the Ice Age in North Dakota.
Most of the narrow, north-south segments of the modern Missouri River Valley correspond to places where glaciers diverted then-existing rivers southward. Glaciers in the central part of the state diverted northeast-flowing rivers, like the Knife, McLean, and Heart-Little Heart, and Cannonball, forcing them to flow southward from the points of diversion, forming the north-south segments of the modern Missouri River. Glaciers advancing into northwestern North Dakota diverted mainly north-flowing rivers, like the Yellowstone and Little Missouri, away from their routes into Canada, forcing them to flow to the east and south.
The modern Missouri River Valley is a “composite” feature, consisting of older, wide pre-glacial segments, formed over long periods of time prior to the Ice Age, along with younger, narrow segments that were cut relatively quickly at various times during the Ice Age. The parts of the Missouri River Valley that extend mainly from west to east are wider and much older than are the narrower segments that extend from north to south. Many of the early “Missouri” River routes followed for varying periods of time during the Ice Age in northern and eastern North Dakota were later buried beneath thick deposits of glacial sediment.
The current route of the modern Missouri River Valley is only the latest in a continuing series. After the next glacier has come and gone, a new version of the Missouri River will likely follow a different route than does the river today.
Glaciation was the main geologic influence on much of North Dakota’s landscape. The Ice Age, a time geologists also refer to as the Pleistocene Epoch, includes most of the past three million years of geologic time. Glaciers advanced over the northern plains several times during the Ice Age, reaching northern and eastern North Dakota. When it wasn’t glaciated, the state had a climate much like the one we enjoy today or possibly even milder at times. the Ice Age wasn’t one long “deep-freeze.”
During their studies of the geology of the state, geologists have found evidence for at least seven separate glaciations, but there may have been more. The most recent of these glaciations is known as the Wisconsinan (because deposits typical of that glaciation are widespread in Wisconsin). The Wisconsinan glaciation began about 100,000 years ago and ended about 11,000 years ago. Some geologists debate whether the Ice Age has really ended yet. After all, large areas of the earth’s surface are still covered by extensive glaciers (Greenland, Antarctica, etc.). It’s likely that we are currently enjoying a lull between major glaciations.
Even though North Dakota was glaciated many times during the Ice Age, it is the Wisconsinan glacial deposits, the most recent ones, that are most obvious to us. These are the ones that form the hills and valleys in eastern and northern North Dakota and they are the ones in which our prairie potholes and wetlands are developed. Most of our richest farmland is developed on the Wisconsinan glacial surface.
Early glaciers, which advanced into North Dakota before the Wisconsinan glacier, also had a profound effect on the state. The materials they deposited have been largely eroded away, and about all that remains of them are occasional boulders — “erratics.” I will discuss erratics elsewhere. It was an early glacier that diverted the course of the Little Missouri River eastward more than 640,000 years ago (possibly earlier). Before that time, the Little Missouri River flowed northward into Canada. In fact, all of North Dakota used to be drained by rivers that flowed into Canada. When it was diverted, the Little Missouri River began to carve the badlands we see today.
All of us who have traveled around North Dakota know that the landscape varies considerably from place to place. Southwestern North Dakota, with its badlands, buttes, and broad vistas is largely the result of hundreds of thousands of years of erosion. The landscape there is not glacial. It has been carved from layers of flat-lying sandstone and other materials.
The Missouri River marks an approximate boundary between the eroded landscape of southwestern North Dakota and the entirely different glacial landscape north and east of the river, where we see small hills – small at least compared to large buttes like Sentinel Butte and Bullion Butte found in southwestern North Dakota. Eastern North Dakota is characterized by thousands of potholes, poorly developed drainage in places, and remarkably fertile farmland.
When the glaciers advanced over the state, they picked up some of the materials over which they flowed. The glaciers contained a variety of kinds of soil and rock, which they eventually deposited as thick layers of sediment. The exposed surface of these sediments has been weathered for the past several thousand years (since the glaciers melted) and it forms the rich soils our farmers work today.
Over much of eastern North Dakota, the glacial sediments were laid down as an undulating plain (think of the Carrington, Finley or Kenmare areas, for example). In other places, a more hilly landscape resulted (think of Turtle Mountain or the Missouri Coteau — places like Belcourt, Hurdsfield, Max, Ryder and countless others). In still other places, water from the melting glacier became ponded, forming huge lakes. Today, most of these areas are flat. Examples of the flat topography may be seen in places like Fargo, Hillsboro, Grand Forks or Grafton. The old floor of Glacial Lake Agassiz (the Red River Valley) is the classic example of flat. Hundreds of smaller glacial lake plains are found in North Dakota too.
As the glaciers flowed over North Dakota, they tended to smooth off and wear down the hill tops and fill in the lower areas with sediment. The overall result is a fairly level landscape. The layers of glacial sediment underlying that landscape are extremely complex, containing buried river channels, blocks of sandstone and shale, old landscapes that were covered many times by fresh glacial sediments. Buried layers of gravel and sand, deposited by water flowing from the melting glacial ice, constitute aquifers. They contain some of our best sources of fresh water.
As the ice flowed, in some places it picked up large chunks of material and moved them short distances before setting them down again. A good example of this is at Devils Lake, where a large amount of material was picked up and moved southward a few miles. Today, Devils Lake lies in a broad lowland. South of the lake is a high range of hills, including Sully’s Hill. The hills consist of materials that were once in the lowland where Devils Lake is now.
In some places, huge floods of water from melting glaciers carved deep river channels. Countless small meltwater valleys, along with some large ones too, are found throughout eastern and northern North Dakota. The Sheyenne, Souris, and James River valleys are good examples of large meltwater valleys. Valley City, Minot, and Jamestown are nestled in meltwater valleys. The Missouri River valley is another example of a glacial river channel, but it had such a complicated history that I’ll plan on writing a special article about it.
How thick were the glaciers that covered North Dakota? Certainly, they were more than a thousand feet thick in the east and north, so thick that the Earth’s crust beneath the ice buckled and sagged downward, eventually rebounding when the ice melted.
Who or what lived in North Dakota during the Ice Age? Mastodons and wooly mammoths lived along the edge of the glacier. Elk, caribou, and horses were common. Horses became extinct in North Dakota and in North America at the end of the Ice Age, They survived, worldwide, because they had migrated to Asia via the land bridge between North America and Asia prior to then. During my field work over the years, I’ve found mastodon teeth, caribou bones and, in the Lake Agassiz deposits, fossil fish bones, mainly perch. It’s likely that early humans also lived here while the most recent glacier was still melting.
I’ve mainly been discussing North Dakota’s glacial landscape. Part of the state, the southwest quarter, was not glaciated, but the glaciers also left their mark there. The badlands along the Little Missouri River owe their existence to early glaciers that diverted the river eastward from its northerly route into Canada. This diversion triggered greatly increased erosion by the Little Missouri River, which resulted in the formation of badlands. Some places that were not glaciated are marked by polygons, formed when permafrost froze the land beyond the limit of the glaciers.